|
View previous topic :: View next topic |
Author |
Message |
for_prof_arc at hotmai... Guest
|
Posted: Sat Dec 18, 2004 11:47 am Post subject: How do we interact with architects? + all similar experts |
|
|
This type of arrogance or burying the head in the sand is nothing new and I have encountered it many times. Probably some SEFI member could compile a list of such damaged structures and these can be sent to such idiots who think non-engineered structures are better than engineered structures.
On a related topic, a few worthy experts who themselves live in their own unsafe old buildings in Dehra Dun and Naini Tal did not bother about their safety but insisted on totally unrealistic high earthquake levels for Tehri Dam without extending the same logic to their towns. They had felt that so far unheard of mega event will occur only at Tehri Site and not anywhere else in Uttaranchal.
In this particular case, I would suggest tht Ms. Sheth write to Gujarat Govt as well as to ASI. Warn them of dire consequences of not following the code post 26Jan2001
ARC ----- Original Message ----- Message From <alpa_sheth@vakilmehtasheth.com> To: <for_prof_arc@hotmail.com> Sent: Saturday, December 18, 2004 4:46 PM Subject: How do we interact with architects?
Quote: | Dear All:
I would like to narrate an experience I had today in an "international"
| conference on Heritage Conservation
Quote: | A Delhi conservation architect, Ms. Gurmeet Rai presented the
| "conservation" of a Gurudwara project in Lakhpat (in Kacchh, Gujarat). She talked about issues of redoing it with lime mortar, redoing the sloping roof etc. To be fair it may have been an architecturally sensitive conservation project. However, nowhere was any seismic retrofit discussed - not even the rudimentary plinth and lintel bands nor the horizontal bracing in roof. And this when the retrofit was being done after the 2001 Bhuj earthquake. Interestingly the project won some kind of UNESCO award too. I raised a query- How is it that you did not think of any seismic retrofit- I even went so far as to say that this retrofit project violated the seismic codes etc and it would never have gone through if it had been brought to the notice of GSDMA (Guj State Disaster Management Authority). Well, needless to say all hell broke loose. The answer I got from Ms Rai was- "We did not think it necessary. And I saw what !
Quote: | others around were doing and did not approve of it"
I was the lone structural engineer who was bombarded with all kinds of
| accusations - "It is reinforced concrete buildings which fail, not the "traditionally" built homes etc. And then there was another lady, a known figure in Delhi "conservation" circles who had the temerity to say that "heritage" structures should not have to follow seismic codes. As per her, Japan does not require heritage buildings to be satisfying seismic requirements. Then, her lady who teaches Conservation Architecture at SPA, Delhi says that at Latur it was new buildings which failed while old traditional buildings that survived. Someone said that a well known structural engineer the previous day had said that good, traditional vernacular buildings had survived and RC buildings had not in the Gujarat earthquake, thereby implying that empirically built buildings perform better than RC buildings.
Quote: | I was aghast at the state of things. I see many major problems.
a) We as Indians appear on the whole not to value life. Worse still, some
| so-called "Conservation" architects have decided to play God with the lives of the lesser folks and want to decide that all heritage buildings (some hospitals in Gujarat also happen to be heritage structures) should be outside the gamut of seismic codes.
Quote: | b) There is a lot of ignorance in the architectural community about
| earthquakes and their behaviour which they have no intention of clearing.
Quote: | c) We fear what we do not know. Many of these architects had not the
| foggiest idea that there can be seismic retrofit in a sensitive manner and so decided that following Codes would mean ungainly intervention.
Quote: | d) Due to the failure of many RC buildings in Ahmedabad and other cities
| we as engineers have lost our credibility. And completely misleading information is being spread about RC buildings vis-a-vis non-engineered structures.
Quote: | I was completely demoralised by the low level of discussions and felt fit
| to quit the conference rather than hear a bunch of people praising the beautiful clothes of a naked Emperor.
Quote: |
But on a serious note, how do we improve the situation?
Cheers, Alpa |
Posted via Email |
|
Back to top |
|
|
|
|
You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum You cannot vote in polls in this forum You can attach files in this forum You can download files in this forum
|
|
|
|